What Kind of Writer Are You Really? A Quiz

This quiz actually started out of curiosity. When I write, I sometimes feel the need to check things that someone else might simply write down and move on from. But I need to know whether a given event really happened in that year, whether something was already in use back then, how long the journey between two cities took, whether that particular building even existed, or whether I've just moved an invention fifty years ahead.

Yes, I'm a nitpicker. And the longer I write, the more I wonder how many people are the same. Because I know writers who won't take a single step without an outline, people who open a document and set off to meet their fate, and then the ones who wanted to write one scene set in 1890 and three hours later have a railway network map, an archive of period photographs and an article about when electricity started being used in homes open on their screen.
So I thought we'd put it to a little test. Not scientifically, no psychological profile will come out of this, but maybe we'll find out whether you're a person with a plan, a person with chaos, or the type who needs to check three more dates and one map before writing a single sentence.
And above all, let me know what you got afterwards. Because I'm honestly curious how many of you feel the need to check things the way I do, and how many people simply write the first draft and don't worry about it at all.
You can click through the quiz right here and your result will be calculated for you. The classic version with letters is below it in a collapsible block.
✦ You might also be interested in ✦
The classic letter version of the quiz
1. You get an idea for a new story. What do you do first?
A) First I need to work out who'll be in it, what they want, where the plot will go and where the whole thing could go wrong. If I have the ending in my head, even better, because then at least I know where I'm dragging all these people the whole time.
B) I open a document and write while the idea is still alive. I genuinely don't know what will happen two chapters from now, because right now I'm dealing with the first scene, and future me has plenty of time to fall apart later.
C) I'll just quickly check something first. When exactly this was used, how long the journey took back then, whether the railway already existed, what the town looked like, whether the characters could even have met the way I've just imagined. An hour later I have fifteen tabs open and haven't written a thing.
2. You're writing a scene set in a specific year. How do you approach it?
A) The year has long been fixed in the timeline. I know what happens before it, what happens after it and why this particular event is exactly where I need it to be.
B) I chose the year because it sounded good. If it later turns out that something doesn't fit at all, I'll hope it can be fixed without the whole story collapsing.
C) The year is where the trouble begins. I need to find out what was happening politically, what already existed, how people dressed, how they travelled, how much things cost and whether I'm accidentally using an expression that appeared thirty years later.
3. What does the folder with your work-in-progress story look like?
A) Chapters, characters, a timeline, relationships, notes, versions and maybe even a spreadsheet of who knows what in which part of the story. When I'm looking for something, I usually really do know where it is.
B) final.docx, final2.docx, new_final.docx, this_one_really_final.docx and one file with a completely nonsensical name, but of course I know that's exactly where the current version is. Usually, anyway.
C) The story itself lies somewhere among maps, period photographs, screenshots from archives, articles about fashion, a list of historical events and a PDF I downloaded for one sentence on page 84. Some of the material has nothing to do with the story anymore, but now that I've found it, I'm certainly not throwing it away.
4. What's your biggest writing nightmare?
A) Discovering halfway through the story that something from the first third makes no logical sense, and because of one mistake everything around it starts to crumble. That's when a very long stare at the document begins, followed by reconstructing half the plot.
B) The first chapters practically write themselves, the characters are alive, the dialogue flows, and then one day, simply nothing. The scene stands still, the people in it stand still too, and I start hoping that the motivation to write will come back on its own someday.
C) Writing a brilliant scene and only then finding out that the historical event happened ten years later, that the journey between the towns took two days back then instead of two hours, or that the thing the character is using didn't even exist yet. Once I know, I unfortunately can't ignore it.
5. Your character arrives in an unfamiliar town. What do you do?
A) I have a rough map, I know where the centre is, who lives there, how the town makes its money, what districts it has and how they relate to each other. The reader will only see a fraction of it, but I need to know that the whole place holds together.
B) First I feel the atmosphere. The streets are wet, the smell of food drifts from somewhere, music is playing in the house next door and my character feels they maybe shouldn't be walking this way. Where the street leads, we'll find out once we walk down it.
C) Before I even let the character in, I need to know how old the houses are, what they're built from, which routes people walked, how transport worked, where people shopped, what the street lighting looked like and whether it was even possible in that year to see on the street the thing I just wanted to describe.
6. A character completely wrecks your original plan mid-writing. What do you do?
A) I rebuild the outline. If the character ended up somewhere other than I expected, fine, but I need to know again what that does to the rest of the plot, the relationships and everything I've already set up.
B) Excellent. We follow them. If they surprised even me, maybe something much better than I originally planned has just been born. We'll deal with future problems when they're actually in the future.
C) First I need to check whether their new decision still fits with what I already know about the world, the period and the circumstances. They can change the direction of the story, but I don't want the rules of reality to suddenly stop applying because of it.
7. You finish the first draft. What comes next?
A) Checking the structure. Whether the plot holds, all the threads lead somewhere, the motivations make sense and nothing was left behind halfway through that looked important and then never appeared again.
B) First I read it as a story. I mostly fix the places where I'm bored, the dialogue doesn't work or the scene feels like it drags. If the text is alive, I deal with the rest afterwards.
C) Time to check the facts, dates, names, distances, technology and all the "CHECK LATER" notes I bravely kept putting off while writing. Which of course means the final check can take longer than the writing itself.
How to work out your result
Just count which letter you have the most of.
Mostly A means The Architect.
Mostly B means The Chaotic Explorer.
Mostly C means The Research Maniac.
If you got a tie, congratulations. You're a Hybrid Disaster and you clearly refuse to write the same way every time.
Results
Mostly A means The Architect
You don't just write a story. You build its structure first and only then let the people in.
You need to know where the plot is going, why it's going there and what happens if someone does something differently. Timelines, continuity and small details that come back ten chapters later are exactly the kind of thing you probably enjoy more than is healthy.
Your strength is that your stories usually feel solid and well thought out. The weaker moment comes when a character dares to have their own opinion and decides to ignore your beautiful plan. That's annoying, but you're probably already drawing up plan B.
Mostly B means The Chaotic Explorer
Above all, you need a feeling, energy and a scene you enjoy. The rest will sort itself out along the way.
You don't write from a map, you watch what happens. The characters decide to change direction, so you go with them. Someone says something you never planned, and suddenly a whole subplot is born that you didn't have an hour ago.
This can create beautifully alive writing, because you discover the story as you go. The harder part comes when you realise you have thirty thousand words and it really would be good to start having some idea where it's all heading.
Future me will deal with it somehow. Hopefully.
Mostly C means The Research Maniac
You don't need everything perfectly planned. But you do need to know that what you're writing makes at least rough sense.
You can get stuck on a date, a street name, a train timetable, a town map or whether a particular piece of technology existed in that year. You only wanted to check something quickly, and an hour later you're reading digitised newspapers from 1912 because you found a mention that might come in handy.
In the end you'll use three sentences of it in the story. But those three sentences will be right, and you'll be happy, because you know you didn't just make them up.
Your only problem is that there comes a point where another source really won't change anything. And that's exactly the moment to close the archive, stop comparing three different maps and go back to the story you originally wanted to write.
A tie means Hybrid Disaster
If you got a tie, you simply refuse to be squeezed into one box, which is actually quite understandable.
Maybe you have the main plot perfectly planned but write individual scenes purely by feel. Maybe you go completely on intuition until a specific historical detail pops up, and then you disappear into the archives for two hours. Or you have spreadsheets, notes and a timeline, but your characters still keep running off somewhere you never meant to let them go.
And maybe this is actually the most common version. Nobody is the same with every project, and one story turns you into a planner while another sends you into total chaos.
What did you get?
Now I'm genuinely curious what you got and whether it fits you. Feel free to tell me which question made you feel suspiciously exposed, because what I really want to know is how many of you feel the need to check things the way I do, and how many people just write and trust that reality will somehow adjust.
If I find out there are more of us research nitpickers, I'll feel a lot less weird.
Yours, Mimosa
Mimosa Confiante

By day, I work somewhere between marketing, copy and campaigns; by night, I usually end up somewhere between fanfiction, cosplay and yet another “what if” that refuses to leave me alone. I write mainly in the Harry Potter and Mo Dao Zu Shi fandoms, most often Snarry, Snamione, HarryLu and WangXian. My healthcare background means that anatomy, medicine and far too much research occasionally find their way into my stories. Cosplay is another way for me to play with the characters I love, whether I stay close to canon or turn them into my own fanfiction and AU versions. In Diary of a Slytherin Girl with ADHD, I write openly about life with a brain that usually has far too many tabs open at once.
📖 More stories on AO3 and Wattpad · 📸 Instagram · 🎥 TikTok · 👉 More about me




Comments